Dashboard: Dec 2020

Jan 5, 2021 | Dashboard


Same Store Sales Trends

Olive Garden was First to Report for the 4Q20 Season

  • Monthly government retail sales data indicates slowing sales momentum in November and a growing premium of QSR CPI prices vs. Food at Home.
  • Olive Garden was the first $1B+ chain to report during the 4Q20 earnings season. OG’s fiscal 2Q21 (ended 11/29) comps declined -19.9%, reflecting tightening capacity restrictions. OG began November with 56 dining rooms closed, growing to 208 by the end of the month (dining room closures during the last 2 weeks of the quarter cost -2% in quarterly comp).
  • In any case, the brand was able to generate average weekly sales at 80% of last year’s results.
  • While declining tourism impacted Georgia, Texas & FL, non-tourist markets in Florida are performing well.
  • Corporate strongly believes that demand for in-restaurant dining is going to come back really strong with some off-premise fall-off. The full-service category was ~$100B and will return to the same level or higher when things normalize (ultimately maintaining its 8% – 9% share of total restaurant sales).
  • Also, the check average remained unchanged (reflecting well on consumer strength) and week-to-week sales in dining rooms that remain open were still growing.


Promotional Composition

More Value is Necessary…

  • The average FSR promotional price point jumped +7.4% in December to the highest level since Oct. 2019????
  • Fortunately, the QSR value promotional mix is beginning to ramp-up although it remains elevated compared to this summer’s levels.


Economic Outlook

4Q Rebound Still in Progress with a Government Backstop

  • 4Q:20 GDP growth outlook pulled back slightly to +8.6% from +11.1% last month according to the GDP Now forecast, including the expectation for a slight improvement in real personal consumption expenditures growth.
  • New $900B economic relief stimulus package (including direct payments up to $600 per person) will start in January with an extension of federal unemployment benefits (up to $300/week through 3/14/21).
  • New business aid includes an additional $284B to fund another round of the Paycheck Protection Program for small businesses (<300 employees & maximum loan amount is $2M vs. $10M in the first round) that can show at least a 25% revenue loss in any calendar quarter in 2020 compared to 2019. PPP loans are forgivable when at least 60% is spent on payroll expenses and restaurants are now able to borrow 3.5X their average monthly payroll (versus 2.5x in first round – unchanged for all other businesses). Business meal deduction has also been expanded to 100% for the next two years.


Key Cost Trends & Forecasts

Commodity & Labor Continue to Ramp-Up

  • Commodity costs continue to rise with the BLS Foodstuffs index posting a new high for the 2nd consecutive month (+7.0% y/y) and the highest level since July 2017.
  • Wage pressure is likely to accelerate in 2021 with 20 states and 32 cities and counties increasing minimum wages on 1/1/21 with an additional 4 states and 18 cities increasing the minimum wage later in the year.
  • Starbucks increased wages for its hourly employees by at least 10% in mid-December and suggested a goal to increase hourly wages to at least $15/hour over the next 2-3 years.


Franchisee EBITDA Valuations

Progress on Unit-Level Valuation Rebound

  • Preliminary 2H:20 RR valuation survey indicates franchisee EBITDA multiples increased +3.1% for QSR and +2.3% for FSR (recovering almost half of the 1H:20 decline), but the 6 month outlook turned more bearish in December.
  • Lending environment is improving especially for strong QSR brands, but underwriting remains more conservative.
  • Also, new PPP program as previously discussed should add considerable liquidity to the sector.
  • M&A activity is expected to pick-up in 2021 including more distressed asset sales.


Stock Performance

RR Index Ends Year in the Black

  • The December RR Index added +4% to its strong +15.9% November gains, helping to propel both QSR & FSR indexes into positive territory for 2020.

Marcus & Millichap Cap Rates

Cap Rates Tick Higher with Rates

Restaurant Research

Email Sign-up

15 Second Posts

What is the Federal Government’s Job?

A couple of weeks ago we conducted a thought experiment in which the government became a nonprofit, and this week we propose another thought experiment in which the government becomes a public corporation. We suggest that this could provide very useful input into the debt ceiling debate.

The Importance of the Balance Sheet in Financial Analysis

While most investors are focused on sales growth & margins, they would be well served to further consider the strength of a company’s balance sheet. We look at BlackRock’s financial condition as an illustrative point.

The Importance of Free Cash Flow in Financial Analysis

Cash represents the lifeblood of all business enterprises which is why it is important to analyze free cash flow which we define as operating cash flow minus capex, dividends, and stock buybacks. We illustrate DoorDash as an example of why cash flow analysis is so important. 

Lessons From Tucker Carlson

There are many theories about why Fox booted Tucker Carlson, but it may be a very simple reason which can instruct everyone involved in the consumer retail segment.

It is Imperative that Climate Change Regs Incorporate Economic Reality

This week we spotlight efforts by international agencies to lower the earth’s temperature by imposing onerous regulations on energy producers. We suggest it will be better to: begin a process of implementing continuous improvements designed to support both economic & climate progress; and use international organizations to share tech & best practices as opposed to providing them with regulatory powers best left to individual nation-states.   

Part 3 – It’s Nice for the US to Save the Climate, But What About the Rest of the World?

In our last 2 posts, we outlined the probability that the UN’s push to lower the world’s temperature by -2 degrees Celsius could drive significant U.S. energy price hikes & shortages. How is this going to help as Asia ramps up the use of coal? Can humans lower the earth’s temperature anyhow?

Part 2: Who is Left to Make Investments in Fossil Fuels & Clean Energy?

There is not a lot of incentive for profit-seeking companies to invest in demonized fossil fuels or in clean energy projects lacking ROI. This points to substantially higher energy prices and supply shortages that will have a profound economic impact.

Part 1: Ramping Energy Demand Clashes with UN’s Environmental Goals

From 2021 to 2050, ExxonMobil forecasts that 85% of the population growth will be driven by developing countries, which in turn, will drive a +15% increase in energy demand.

What if the Federal Government Was Turned into a 501c3 Non-Profit?

Given all the focus on the debt ceiling, we propose a thought experiment in which all 100 federal agencies must compete for charitable donations. If taxpayers get to choose for themselves what to fund, what might we learn? 

Like Sinatra Croons: “So you see it’s all up to you, you can be better than you are.”

The top-paid hourly workers are currently enjoying the fastest wage growth, indicative of the current challenge to recruit & retain a skilled labor force.

Digital Marketing Opportunities
Restaurant Research

A Restaurant Research LLC Company