Panera is the largest fast casual player with a well-established cafe-bakery positioning around “food that tastes good & is good for you” with a menu featuring fresh/healthful ingredients, “foodie offers” and seasonal options/flavors. The brand seeks to move in front of the curve as it relates to a shift in diet preferences away from a culture of “shame & guilt” to “food positivity” in which consumers add more healthful ingredients (like leafy greens) to their meals, and, to this end, Panera will make plant-based options available in every menu category. The chain’s “food as it should be” marketing highlights its core brand equity which easily contrasts with some competitors that leverage processed ingredients to provide an abundance of lower quality, lower priced food. Panera’s ongoing menu evolution includes the addition of: improved breakfast offerings; “heartier” dinner options; non-carbonated & moderately sweetened beverage choices; and an upgraded coffee/espresso platform consistent with its parent company (JAB holdings) portfolio of specialty coffee chains. The goal is to expand beyond its core lunch daypart with menu items better suited for breakfast & dinner. Notably, while Panera offers a dine-in environment well-suited to hang-out, efforts to better appeal to those time-starved and on-the-go include advancements in its digital order & access platforms that are driving the chain’s e-commerce sales mix towards the level enjoyed by the national pizza chains. The brand also benefits from the development of what has become the industry’s largest loyalty program which drives substantially higher frequency among its members. Delivery has been attributed with driving recent comp growth and Panera recently boosted its positioning by adding DSP origination partnerships to its own in-house delivery platform. Having said all this, Panera’s sales are challenged by a sharp increase in industry discounting and while its business model may appeal to its core customers, it is less appealing to value seeking consumers at the margin. Panera’s positioning is also challenged by strong competition from other fast casual players and QSR+ as well as casual players providing greater value and faster service speeds at lunch. Further, the chain faces increasing competition from VC and private equity funded “better food” restaurant start-ups which target the urban, millennial crowd with cutting-edge culinary trends. Another notable challenge comes from operational complexities driven by a very large menu, a very high level of new product innovation and a plethora of new business initiatives. In conclusion, while Panera has a sound long-term strategy, there are many moving parts that challenge its operations and a value-oriented business environment that challenge its upscale positioning.
Panera
Mar 10, 2020 | Report Announcements
Email Sign-up
Powell Faults an Overheated Labor Market for the Need to Hike Rates Again
Despite growing evidence of systematic bank risks associated with the Fed’s aggressive rate hikes over the last year, Powell hikes another 25 bps anyhow, citing labor pressure as the culprit. However, in the real world, labor conditions are already improving.
Fixed-Income Issuance Says a Lot About Economy
Total U.S. fixed income (FI) issuance declined -34% y/y to $8.8 trillion during 2022 as interest rates ramped up.
Bank Deposits Growing Much Faster than Business Loan Demand
Banks have been parking excess deposits in various forms of government debt that are subject to interest rate risk & in some cases, risky crypto bets. This is causing systematic risk.
Nerdwallet Survey Shows an Indebted & Very Stressed Consumer
Consumers are combating the higher price of living & higher interest rates by driving less, buying store brands & taking on more debt.
The United States of America is Worth Saving
Americans need to be reminded about our heritage as the single most productive nation as measured by GDP/person with a unique capability to bless the entire world if we can simply get back to business.
Should Private Banks Go Extinct?
Since the 2008 Great Recession, 134 banks with assets of $1.25 Trillion have been closed by regulators. At the same time, the Fed’s ballooning balance sheet now amounts to nearly 50% of total domestic bank deposits.
What Happened to Silicon Valley Bank?
Don’t assume that SVB’s difficulties are symbolic of the entire banking industry.
What Does the End of the Petrodollar Mean?
The Saudi minister of finance announced that the Kingdom was ending the petrodollar. “There are no issues with discussing how we settle our trade arrangements, whether it is in the US dollar, whether it is the euro, whether it is the Saudi riyal”. Yikes!
Senator Kennedy Schools Country on Economics 101
We have a choice of how to tame inflation, cut government spending, or throw people out of work.
Inflation is Marginalizing Purchasing Power from the Lower-Income Demo
As households with annual incomes >$70k drive 62% of total food-away-from-home sales, it is more important than ever to focus on this demo especially as spending from the lower-income demo slows.
A Restaurant Research LLC Company